Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ravishing Rudey's avatar

The amount of mindless celebratory 5-star reviews for the Google Critter's book are deeply disappointing (who doesn't love it when an economist points out the obvious and believes he is somehow insightful). Good reminder for people who use online reviews to make purchasing decisions: Ignore the 5-star reviews, pay more attention to the 4-star and 2-star ones... Less likely to be fake and more likely to articulate what they actually think.

Expand full comment
the suck of sorrow's avatar

Shortly after 7 October 2023 Seymour Hersh wrote an article whose source was an IDF officer that predicted the demise of the Hamas force within the next two weeks. His reports on things Gaza, Israel and Iran have not improved in the meantime.

What does confuse me about Hersh is the timeline of Israel's history. I am 71, Israel as a state was a done deal before my birth. As a child I was basked in propaganda about the righteousness of Israel and the valor of the IDF. Hersh is 87. I am surprised that he did not develop a skepticism of Israeli propaganda a long time ago.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts